AlburyCity Council has accepted the findings of a NSW Audit Office examination of its finances, saying it is important the findings are accurately understood in the context of the overall audit outcome.
In its report, which was released last week, the NSW Audit Office highlighted a core General Fund operating deficit of $10.79 million alongside several governance and financial oversights, including an authorised bank signatory who was a former employee, unexplained variances in cash balances, a breach of TCorp lending rules regarding a $34 million debt, $7.4 million in completed infrastructure omitted from the Council’s asset register, and $1.3 million in uncollected Federal road upgrade and repairs funding.
The Audit Office issued an unmodified audit opinion on the Council’s financial statements and assessed the matters identified as moderate or low impact. The audit also found no reportable issues relating to legislative compliance and no evidence of management override of controls.
“Over the past 18 months, Council has undertaken significant work to strengthen financial reporting, improve controls, reconcile historical discrepancies and build a much clearer picture of our long-term financial position,” said Council CEO, Jason Gordon.
“We expected that work to identify issues requiring correction and improvement, particularly in the first year.
“Our focus remains firmly on addressing those challenges through stronger financial management, continuous improvement and delivery of Council’s Financial Sustainability Program.
“Importantly, the independent auditor concluded that AlburyCity’s financial statements fairly present Council’s financial position, with no material deficiencies in the accounting records or financial statements identified through the audit.
“We have accepted the audit findings and are already progressing the actions needed to strengthen our systems and processes further.
“Transparency means being upfront with our community about the challenges as well as the progress we are making.
“Council has made the Audit Office report publicly available alongside its audited financial statements. We believe openness, accountability and access to the facts are fundamental to building community confidence.”
Council’s Roads to Recovery funding multi-year funding arrangement came under scrutiny by the Audit Office, after Council chose to carry the funding forward to support its future works program.
“This approach reflects Council’s commitment to careful financial management and ensuring available funding is directed to priority infrastructure projects at the right time,” it said in a statement.
A finding related to the debt service cover ratio arose in the context of Council repaying approximately $35 million in external TCorp debt and replacing that borrowing with an internal loan from the Water Fund. The $35 million internal loan had financial benefits, including reducing Council’s external debt and borrowing costs, and was approved by the Office of Local Government.
The subsequent audit identified an issue with how it affected Council’s debt service cover ratio.
“That experience has informed our approach, and future borrowing decisions, will be considered against their broader impact on Council’s financial sustainability,” the Council stated.
The audit also examined the integrity of Council’s financial statements and relevant controls and processes.
“AlburyCity has been completely open about the remaining financial challenge, and the fact that it could take multiple years to work through a program to reduce deficits. The audited result shows a $16.2 million improvement in Council’s consolidated operating result compared with the previous year, with a reduction in the deficit from $26.4 million to $10.8 million. While significant progress has been made, it is recognised that financial challenges remain and there is more work ahead.”
Albury Mayor, Kylie King said it was important the community understands the purpose of the audit report.
“An external audit is an independent review designed to provide assurance and identify opportunities for improvement,” she said.
“Scrutiny is welcome and appropriate. It is important that discussions about the audit are based on the audit itself and the full context of its findings.
“We will not shy away from scrutiny, we will act on what needs improving, and we will continue to be transparent with our community.
“These results show real progress is being made. We’ve improved our operating result by $16.2 million and are moving in the right direction, while remaining open about the fact there is still significant work required to achieve long-term financial sustainability.
“Community confidence is built when we focus on facts, transparency and the actions needed to address challenges.
“Behind every service, project and decision are dedicated employees who live locally, care deeply about our city and work hard every day to deliver outcomes for the benefit of the community.
“Thank you to those you have, and continue to, engage, positively and constructively with myself, Councillors and staff with respectful dialogue, even where views and opinions differ. It is appreciated. I know it is a sign that we love our city and want the best for the community and I encourage us all to work together on what comes next.”
Council’s Audit, Risk and Improvement Committee Chair, Stephen Coates said he was confident the matters identified by the Audit Office were being addressed through appropriate governance and improvement processes.
“The Committee has maintained oversight of Council’s financial management, risk and control environment throughout this period and will continue to monitor management’s response to the audit findings,” he said.
“Actions arising from the audit will be added to Council’s audit action register and regularly reported back to the Committee. Management has already advised that a number of the identified actions are either complete or underway, reflecting the fact that improvement is an ongoing process.
“Importantly, the report indicates Council’s financial statements are expected to receive an unmodified audit opinion, with findings assessed as moderate or low impact. The audit found no reportable issues relating to legislative compliance and no evidence of management override of controls.
“It is not unusual for audits to identify opportunities for improvement. The key question is whether those matters are identified, reported transparently and addressed appropriately. In this case, established governance processes have operated as intended and improvement actions are under way.”

